View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0001562||Scribus||Graphics / Image Frames||public||2005-01-18 01:40||2010-11-04 16:31|
|Target Version||1.5.0||Fixed in Version||1.5.0svn|
|Summary||0001562: "Scale to frame size" locks the image in the frame: no more free positionning|
|Description||When the option "Scale to frame size" is checked, there is no way to freely and simply move the image around within its frame.|
What I understand (and I agree!) is the proportions have to be fixed to that image frame because this is the purpose of this option. But I think preventing users from *moving* the image *at that scale* into the image frame is a bit restrictive.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
|moving to 1.2.2.. fixable ?|
Last edited: 2005-04-10 18:18
I played with this a bit and the current behaviour seems sane to me. If I scale an image to a frame, I want the image locked to that frame.
The workaround if you will is trivial. Switch back to free scaling and the image can be moved within a frame. Scribus is 'well-behaved' in that it does not adjust the scaling any further - unless - you explicitly change it.
I certainly would put this as a feature request, not a bug honestly..At this point, I cannot recommend a change to current stable 1.2.2cvs. I am open to be persauded, as always.
Bumping to 1.3 as a feature.
||Disagree. Scale to frame size means just that, does not relate to positioning within the frame.|
||what about automatically switching to free scaling if user requests to move the picture?|
Reminder sent to: cbradney,
cbradney, plinell: "acknowledged" or "won't fix"?
||jo-hannes' idea makes the most sense to me.|
||I'm still of the opinion that theres free scaling/scaled to frame size and that whether its locked to the frame's origin is a separate matter and this restriction just shouldn't be there.|
||Exactly. We don't expect something to be locked unless we locked it.|
yes, i completely agree.
me (and my girlfriend, too) think that the image frame misses one important option:
to scale/crop/move an image _inside_ the frame and then being able to scale that frame as itself by dragging it`s borders - with the contents then resizing appropriate (proportional or not proportional)
there is no easy way to do this now - typically you need to rework that image in an external program (gimp or whatelse)
the current behaviour seems a little bit too restrictive - sort of "all or nothing". If i set "scale to frame size" it always refers to the complete image.
||Scribus already crops by the way..|
you mean you select properties->edit shape->move-nodes?
yes, we can crop with that - but did you ever try to resize that cropped image then?
with "free scaling", the frame and the shape scales, but not the image inside.
with "scale to frame" the _whole_ image will always be "refitted" automatically to the frame.
what is missing here is some "lock/unlock" option.
||No, just move the resize handles|
||Reminder on the road to 1.4 (please also let me know if this is ok to remind!)|
|This is an old bug which shold get resolved one way or another.|
|2005-01-18 01:40||louisdesjardins||New Issue|
|2005-01-18 13:34||cbradney||Relationship added||related to 0000052|
||Note Added: 0004137|
||Product Version||1.2.1 => 1.2.2cvs|
||Note Added: 0004223|
||Note Edited: 0004223|
||Severity||tweak => feature|
||Product Version||1.2.2cvs => 1.3|
|2005-04-11 15:37||cbradney||Note Added: 0004230|
|2006-01-28 14:29||jo-hannes||Note Added: 0008439|
|2006-04-15 17:45||mhanski||Note Added: 0010011|
|2006-04-29 20:24||mhanski||Status||new => feedback|
|2006-04-29 20:29||christoph_s||Note Added: 0010636|
|2006-04-30 03:57||PLucAuclair||Note Added: 0010671|
|2006-04-30 08:59||cbradney||Note Added: 0010677|
|2006-04-30 11:00||louisdesjardins||Note Added: 0010693|
|2006-06-04 15:18||devzero||Note Added: 0011571|
|2006-06-04 23:56||PLucAuclair||Note Added: 0011574|
|2006-06-05 00:10||devzero||Note Added: 0011575|
|2006-06-05 00:11||devzero||Note Edited: 0011575|
|2006-06-05 00:24||PLucAuclair||Note Added: 0011576|
|2008-02-05 18:52||christoph_s||Relationship added||related to 0005662|
|2010-02-16 16:54||louisdesjardins||Note Added: 0023301|
||Note Added: 0023363|
||Status||feedback => new|
||Target Version||=> 1.4.0svn|
|2010-06-14 20:34||cbradney||Target Version||1.4.0svn => 1.4.0|
|2010-11-03 21:33||cbradney||Status||new => resolved|
|2010-11-03 21:33||cbradney||Fixed in Version||=> 1.5.0svn|
|2010-11-03 21:33||cbradney||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2010-11-03 21:33||cbradney||Assigned To||=> cbradney|
|2010-11-03 21:34||cbradney||Target Version||1.4.0 => 1.5.0|
|2010-11-04 16:31||cbradney||Status||resolved => closed|
|2015-09-17 20:10||Kunda||Category||Graphics / Image Frames => Graphics/Img Frames|
|2015-09-17 20:11||Kunda||Category||Graphics/Img Frames => Graphics / Image Frames|