View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0011647||Scribus||Graphics / Image Frames||public||2013-07-07 19:28||2016-12-08 22:04|
|Platform||Mac||OS||OS X||OS Version||10.6.8|
|Summary||0011647: Alignment functions don't work uniformally with lines of width greater than hairline|
|Description||When you have a line that has a width greater than hairline the alignment functions don't work correctly all the time. See steps and forum post mentioned below.|
Merged from 0014020 "Lines that are widened don't snap to margins correctly"
Observations when viewing line-doesnt-snap-correct.gif line-doesnt-snap-correct2.gif a) the narrow end of the line if attempted to snap perpendicularly will show the preview incorrectly (juts out farther then the margin/guide) but snaps correctly when mouse is disengaged b) the sides of the line if attempted to snap parallel to a margin/guide will not snap line correctly to the edge but instead to the midline of the line itself Steps to Reproduce: 1) Draw a line (Press L and hold command key to keep orientation to 0 degrees) 2) Go to PP > Line > Line Width and set to 20pt 3) Click on line and drag it to one of the margins or a guide Result: Dragging perpendicular or parallel will show incongruent behavior mentioned above in a) and b)
|Steps To Reproduce||One example:|
1. Create horizontal line (0 degrees).
2. Make line wider (e.g. 30pt).
3. Create frame.
4. Select line and frame together.
5. Use "Centre on horizontal axis" alignment tool.
The frame is aligned to the outside of the line rather than the actual line itself.
|Additional Information||See forum post http://forums.scribus.net/index.php/topic,1006.0.html for more details and examples.|
|related to||0014021||closed||jghali||Widened & Rotated line that is grouped with another object shows abnormal outline when grouped|
|related to||0013887||confirmed||Arrows should snap to the end of the arrow (and not the base of the arrow instead) for margins/marks/grids/objects etc...|
|related to||0013706||confirmed||Changing Line width renders line incorrectly when selected|
|related to||0011932||new||Snapping to guides doesn't work at high zoom levels|
|related to||0013858||confirmed||Snap to Items preview does not always respect final item placement|
|has duplicate||0014020||closed||Lines that are widened don't snap to margins correctly|
|has duplicate||0014161||closed||jghali||central division of double page layout in scribus does not match PDF output|
|related to||0012330||new||Bad selection X,Y for thick lines|
||Maybe this has been fixed in 1.5 ?|
||Unfortunately, since upgrading to Mavericks, I can't recompile 1.5.0svn to check. (cmake presents an error that I can't resolve with my minimal technical knowledge, but that's irrelevant here.) Maybe someone else can check this?|
I confirm the bug happens on 1.5.
As stated in the forum, it only happens when line angle is 0°.
scribusdoc.cpp (12779) (yes : 12779) reads as follow :
The XYZ pane of the PP displays the height of a line object to be allways 0.353mm (but greyed), even if the line has a strong thickness, like 10mm.
All the same, there is no "center on vertical axis" placement issue when angle is not 0°.
So the XYZ "witdh" entry of the PP does not display the value of the "width" property used in the formula ? Hmm
Reproduced with 1.4.4 (19167) and 1.5.0 (19179)
The issue is also very visible when bottoms/tops are aligned.
||Just noticed now, why is the priority set to Low? It should be as least Normal.|
||I think I set it to "Low" priority when I created the issue originally. I don't mind if it's bumped up the list of priorities.|
||I tried to fix this a few weeks ago.. its requires a lot of work. Its not a quick fix. Likely 12-24h of solid work. Moving to 1.5.1 roadmap|
||Issue has been replicated in 1.4.5. (Changed product version number in ticket as appropriate.)|
A similar problem occurs when you have thick lines and are resizing a shape using snap to grid/guides.
Basically, once you change the width of the line of a shape, the snapping functions work to the visible part of the shape rather than the line itself. See attached GIF (grid snap) to see it in action.
||looks like i created a dupe in 0014020|
A similar issue can be observed in 0013887 "Arrows at the end of a line should point to the end of the line, not further away"
Also encountered 0013706 when reproducing this ticket
|2013-07-07 19:28||GarryP||New Issue|
|2014-04-07 15:43||JLuc||Note Added: 0031645|
|2014-04-08 09:30||GarryP||Note Added: 0031651|
|2014-04-08 12:35||JLuc||Note Added: 0031652|
|2014-04-08 12:35||JLuc||Note Edited: 0031652|
|2014-04-08 14:15||JLuc||Tag Attached: easyhack|
|2014-04-08 21:02||JLuc||Tag Detached: easyhack|
|2014-04-08 21:07||JLuc||Note Edited: 0031652|
|2014-04-08 22:20||JLuc||Note Edited: 0031652|
|2014-04-09 16:09||JLuc||Note Edited: 0031652|
|2014-04-09 16:11||JLuc||Note Edited: 0031652|
|2014-06-04 18:39||FirasH||Note Added: 0032014|
|2014-06-05 11:42||FirasH||Note Added: 0032024|
|2014-06-06 08:59||GarryP||Note Added: 0032033|
|2014-06-25 00:43||FirasH||Status||new => confirmed|
|2014-06-25 20:13||cbradney||Note Added: 0032314|
|2014-06-25 20:13||cbradney||Target Version||=> 1.5.1|
|2015-02-02 09:54||GarryP||Patch||=> No|
|2015-02-02 09:54||GarryP||Product Version||1.4.2 => 1.4.5|
|2015-02-02 09:54||GarryP||Note Added: 0034427|
|2015-09-17 20:10||Kunda||Category||Graphics / Image Frames => Graphics/Img Frames|
|2015-09-17 20:11||Kunda||Category||Graphics/Img Frames => Graphics / Image Frames|
|2016-01-23 17:17||cbradney||Target Version||1.5.1 => 1.5.3|
|2016-05-04 12:11||GarryP||File Added: grid snap.gif|
|2016-05-04 12:11||GarryP||Note Added: 0040765|
|2016-05-04 13:57||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0014020|
|2016-05-04 13:58||Kunda||Note Added: 0040769|
|2016-05-04 14:00||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0014021|
|2016-05-10 15:39||Kunda||File Added: line-doesnt-snap-correct.gif|
|2016-05-10 15:42||Kunda||Note Added: 0040938|
|2016-05-10 15:42||Kunda||Description Updated|
|2016-05-10 15:42||Kunda||Additional Information Updated|
|2016-05-10 15:44||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0013887|
|2016-05-10 15:44||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0013706|
|2016-05-10 15:44||Kunda||File Added: line-doesnt-snap-correct2.gif|
|2016-05-10 15:46||Kunda||Relationship replaced||has duplicate 0014020|
|2016-05-10 15:47||Kunda||Description Updated|
|2016-05-23 13:47||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0012330|
|2016-05-23 14:02||Kunda||Tag Attached: snapping|
|2016-05-23 14:02||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0011932|
|2016-05-23 14:05||Kunda||Note Added: 0041344|
|2016-05-23 14:05||Kunda||Relationship added||related to 0013858|
|2016-06-18 12:18||jghali||Relationship added||has duplicate 0014161|
|2016-12-08 22:04||Kunda||Target Version||1.5.3 => 1.5.4|